Thursday, November 06, 2008

Meth by powerpoint

Powerpoint presentations and other files from the Global Methamphetamine Conference are here.

Wednesday, November 05, 2008

The social cost of smoking

Tobacco use is continuing its transition from celebrated to tolerated and is slinking in the direction of prohibition.

Election roundup

Join Together has put together a roundup of the election ballot proposals.

Looks like it was a good day for marijuana advocates and mixed day for other areas of the drug war.

A Peek Inside Heroin Maintenance

Robert's story:
Long-time addict Robert Vincent says he's living proof that getting free, daily heroin can improve the quality of a drug user's life, possibly steering him closer to recovery.

"I wasn't waking up in the middle of the night worrying where I was going to get the money to get my fix," said Mr. Vincent, who speaks with a slight lisp, the result of large gaps between his teeth. "I started to eat better, regain my appetite."

Mr. Vincent, 36, was one of 115 men and women, all diehard heroin addicts, who were part of a groundbreaking but controversial Canadian medical trial, called NAOMI - the North American Opiate Medication Initiative - which doled out free heroin for a year to addicts in Vancouver and Montreal. Others in the study received methadone or hydromorphone, a prescription painkiller.

Its preliminary results were released last month, with researchers concluding that most addicts committed fewer crimes and took better care of themselves when they didn't have to steal and panhandle to support their pricey heroin habits. They say they will use the results to press the government to consider free heroin as a treatment option for incurable addicts.

Mr. Vincent, they say, is an example of how an addict's life can improve when freed from the constraints of scrounging for money to feed a costly, illegal habit. While on the study, Mr. Vincent left the street, found an apartment, landed a job and gained 30 pounds.

But then the free heroin stopped.

Today, he is back living on the street, delving through back-alley garbage bins for returnable bottles to earn money to buy drugs. He said he uses street-purchased morphine and hydromorphone. The day after an initial interview with The Globe and Mail, Mr. Vincent failed to show up for a follow-up meeting. He was spotted a few hours later standing outside Vancouver's supervised injection site, his eyes fluttering and his chin drooped on his chest. He was clearly high.
To be sure, Robert's crash will be presented as evidence for and against the effectiveness of heroin maintenance. What I found most revealing was this line: "...researchers...say they will use the results to press the government to consider free heroin as a treatment option for incurable addicts."

Who knows whether the researchers used the word incurable, but the reporter was given that impression. Says it all, doesn't it? What treatments have or haven't been tried for these incurable addicts? What do they want?

Strange bedfellows. A methadone advocate weighs in:
"There is a fine line between harm reduction and enabling," said Stanley deVlaming, who has treated addicts in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside for years. Dr. deVlaming believes the study, which he says was based largely on self-reporting, was politicized. Severely addicted people knew that if they responded positively to the free heroin, it could bolster the chances of receiving the illegal drug down the road.

Dr. deVlaming argues that the best way to treat heroin addiction is with methadone, a synthetic drug that helps prevent withdrawal sickness but does not induce euphoria.

"For many of these patients, if I hand them their heroin, if I make it easier for them to stay addicted, am I doing them any favours?" Dr. deVlaming asked. "When I treat a patient, I often say that I am treating two sides of that person. There's one side that's trying to get better and there's that side of them, the addicted side, that wants to stay addicted. I try to align myself with the side of them that wants to get better."
From another physician:
Another Vancouver addiction physician, Milan Khara, said doctors who speak against the effectiveness of the heroin trials have been harassed, as have those who have criticized another so-called harm-reduction initiative, Vancouver's supervised injection site.

Dr. Khara criticized the NAOMI results, saying he too thinks the participants in the heroin study were motivated to report positive results.

"At the end of the day, these individuals have an addiction," he said. "If they believe their answers are going to lead to a lifetime of free heroin, their answers become highly unreliable.
PICC lines anyone?
Dr. deVlaming says he has concerns too with any treatment that involves daily injections, which often cause serious infections in the heart, spine or bones. "There is nothing safe about repeated daily injections directly into your veins," he said.
From a research subject:
Greg Liang, an addict who was part of the heroin trial, says the program helped stabilize his life. Mr. Liang felt tremendous relief at not having to hustle for money to buy drugs. The NAOMI heroin was pure and uncut, providing a longer high than street heroin. "It was quite delicious," he said in an interview at a Vancouver coffee shop.

But Mr. Liang, 41, who began using drugs at 18, says the free heroin made him complacent about his addiction. Other addicts, he says, took advantage of the free heroin, even competing for how much they could consume each day. For some, their habits grew worse. "They were heroin pigs," he said, shaking his head.

After nine months on the heroin trial, Mr. Liang says, he switched to methadone because he knew it would be hard to stop cold turkey when the study ended.

Today, Mr. Liang is still using heroin and cocaine. He says he's not sure if the heroin program helped his addiction. Like Mr. Vincent, his quality of life improved for a period. He began volunteering for the city of Vancouver, helping addicts. It eventually became a paid, part-time position.

But Mr. Liang says his life is still controlled by drugs. A stressful day can set off a binge. He thinks the only way to quit drugs is to move far from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, where there are scores of services for addicts.
I want to repeat what Mr. Liang said, "the only way to quit drugs is to move far from Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, where there are scores of services for addicts."

He feels his only hope is to get away from the professionals that are trying to help addicts!!! (Read our position paper on harm reduction. Note that it's not against harm reduction.)

A closing thought from the lead researcher:
Martin Schechter, NAOMI's chief investigator, said researchers have no qualms about giving addicts free heroin and denied the program helped enable their addictions.

"This is a way of providing a maintenance therapy that allows them to get out of the street cycle of illicit drugs because these people are injecting heroin right now," Dr. Schechter said. "It's not like we're starting them on heroin. They're on it now. So the question is: Who do you want prescribing it? You have the black market or doctors or nurses."
I'd like to hear more about the values that drive his practice. Maybe the next trial should include PICC lines?

Online recovery support

I've been waiting for a large treatment program to implement a web-based recovery support program. I've been curious to see what it might look like and how they would navigate privacy issues.

MORE is hardly innovative. We'll see what future iterations look like.

Extended vs Short-term Buprenorphine for Young Opiate Addicts

In a study with subjects receiving low intensity outpatient treatment, those who received buprenorphine for 12 weeks did significantly better than those receiving it for 2 weeks.

The difference in retention is striking 70% for extended detox, compared with 20% for short term detox. There were also improved short term and 12 month outcomes in opiate and cocaine use. Outcomes related to alcohol and marijuana use were comparable and pretty low in both groups.

One of the reported limitations was this:
We had no way to compare these results with intensive outpatient therapy, residential treatment, therapeutic community, or naltrexone. It was impossible to design a random assignment study including the first 3 options because they are in limited supply, and the programs we contacted did not feel comfortable using an agonist medication with this population except for short-term detoxification.
What, exactly, was responsible for the improved outcomes? I suspect that most of the benefits, particularly long term, are related to enhanced treatment retention. (As a treatment provider, of course I'd think this!)

Other questions:
  • To what degree are these benefits a function of the low intensity of treatment?
  • What would the disparity be like if more recovery support been provided? If they were provided intense treatment?
  • Unfortunately, we have to ask, what have unpublished studies found?

Tuesday, November 04, 2008

Monday, November 03, 2008

Michigan's medical marijuana proposal

Michigan has a ballot proposal that, if passed, will legalize medical marijuana. It looks like it will easily pass. Moreover, it seems to be getting very little attention--it's noncontroversial.

How did we get here? I think it's safe to say that this proposal would have been a major flashpoint 8 years ago. In fact, I attended a treatment provider meeting 8 years ago only to suffer through a presentation by a local prosecutor about a marijuana ballot proposal in which he repeatedly referred to George Soros and others as "crack daddies."

This time around most people seem to be barely aware of the proposal and few people seem to have strong feelings. Yesterday is the first time I remember seeing a commercial. I've seen no serious analysis of the proposal. No one seems to be seriously wrestling with questions like the following:
  • Is marijuana good medicine?
  • Does this proposal integrate lessons from other states like California?
  • has legalization of medical marijuana led to increased marijuana use by teens or lowered the age of first use?
  • Are there other options (like Savitex) that are better?
  • Instead of changing state constitutions one at a time, should we pressing for unbiased clinical trials and if those trials merit it, have the FDA seriously review it for approval? 
  • Are there legitimate reasons for the FDA to withhold approval? If so, is this a good way to make medical policy?
  • How many cancer or MS patients have been arrested for using marijuana?
My suspicion is that the reason there's no serious discussion of these questions is because it's too difficult to trust what anyone has to say on the subject. We've all been held hostage by the drug policy freak show with the ONDCP on one side and legalization advocates on the other. We know the drug war is a disaster but we're not comfortable with decriminalization and we hate the drug policy war too. It's spilled beyond drug enforcement policy and is polluting discussion of treatment and prevention. We feel like we can't trust what anyone says, so we just tune it all out. 

In this way, the drug war is the gift that keeps on giving. 

Sunday, November 02, 2008

One more reason to quit smoking

An explanation for the impact of continued smoking on recovery rates?
A study of alcoholics in treatment for their alcohol problems used brain scans to examine how performance on cognitive tests changes with abstinence from alcohol. Twenty-five alcoholics stopped drinking for six to nine months, but the 12 who smoked continued to smoke.

“We found that the smoking alcoholics over six to nine months of abstinence did not recover certain types of brain function as the non-smoking alcoholics did,” said study author Dieter J. Meyerhoff, a professor of radiology at the University of California, San Francisco. Decision-making skills, thinking speed, 3-D visualization and short-term memory were affected, calling into question the prospects of long-term sobriety, he noted.

And while smoking and non-smoking alcoholics improved on several other cognitive tests, such as learning and remembering words, smokers’ brain function, in general, took longer to recover.

[hat tip: jointogether.org]

Fixing National Drug Control Policy

A new drug policy brief is getting some attention:
Decades of research has taught us a good deal about the ingredients of a successful national drug control strategy. Achieving any measure of progress requires a comprehensive agenda involving treatment, prevention, domestic law enforcement, interdiction, and source country initiatives. But these ingredients are not all of equal value and represent very different returns on investment.

Attacking drugs at their source by focusing mostly on eradication is expensive and unproductive....

Investing in prevention and treatment is a more effective means of reducing drug demand and use. However, the scale and scope of substance abuse treatment must be greatly expanded to further mitigate drug use and addiction. Community based treatment programs, as well as prevention programs, such as Drug Free Communities and Weed and Seed, are particularly valuable in this regard. In addition, research shows that diversion programs, such as drug courts, that emphasize treatment over incarceration and use the coercive power of the criminal justice system in a productive way, are effective and should be greatly expanded.

A small portion of the drug-using population—specifically those who are addicted—consume well over two-thirds of the illicit drugs that law enforcement tries to prevent from entering the United States. Helping these individuals to stop using drugs would substantially reduce the quantity of drugs demanded by the marketplace. In other words: Good treatment policy is smart supply reduction policy.
The goals implicit in a national drug control strategy should drive the federal drug control budget....But instead we have a budget that over-weights source country and interdiction initiatives while under-weighting their domestic law enforcement, prevention, and treatment counterparts. According to the latest budget numbers, funding for supply reduction has increased by nearly 57 percent since federal fiscal year 2002 and now represents nearly two-thirds of the total federal drug control budget. By comparison, funding for demand reduction grew by less than 3 percent over this same period of time and now represents about one-third of the federal drug control budget. While resources for substance abuse treatment increased by 22 percent, resources for prevention programs actually declined by almost 25 percent.

The implications are clear: Any new administration must ensure that there is a match between the goals of the federal drug control strategy and the budget to support it.

Saturday, November 01, 2008

Revisiting spiritual guidance in treatment

Bill White has a response to the Bill Miller study on the effectiveness (or lack of effectiveness) of spiritual guidance in an addiction treatment setting. He warns against throwing the baby out with the bath water and offers a series of questions about spiritual guidance, recovery and treatment:
  • How are the following defined and delineated:spirituality, spiritual awakening, spiritual orientation,spiritual practices, and SG? What is the relationship between spirituality, life meaning and purpose, andquality of life?
  • Does the essence of spiritual experience get lost in efforts to artificially define and replicate it within a professional treatment intervention? Are the ingredients of spiritually oriented professional interventions the same as the ingredients that people in long-term recovery self-report as transformative?
  • Will individuals entering or leaving treatment voluntarily participate in a spiritually based intervention? It is unclear in the two SG studies whether the low participation rates (means of 2.9 and 4.8 sessions attended of 12 sessions) were a function of the characteristics of study subjects, the design, and content of the intervention offered or were influenced by staff or organizational factors.
  • Are there dose, duration, and timing effects of spiritually oriented interventions? Would different outcomes of the SG studies have been achieved if the dose (number of sessions attended) had been larger or if SG had been delivered as a program for treatment alumni with at least 1 year of sobriety? Are the effects of spirituality and SG different across the long-term stages of recovery?
  • What is the role of choice in the spirituality experience and the SG process? Does the “having had a spiritual awakening” effect of AA's 12 Steps result from the individual ingredients of the steps, the cumulative effects of such ingredients, or the sequence in which these actions were taken? Are there greater effects from a focused exposure to a single spiritual philosophy/practice or, as with the SG studies, self-choosing exposure to multiple spiritual practices?
  • Is there an ecology of spiritual experience? The milieu of the SG studies (addiction treatment institution) is markedly different than the milieu of 12 Step and alternative recovery support groups (community of shared experience). What effects do physical and cultural environment exert on spiritual experience?
  • Does the relational context matter? There is considerable difference between the professional–client relationship with professionals not having prior experience working with addicted and recovering people (as in the SG studies) and relationships in recovery support groups that are characterized by moral equality, mutual vulnerability, mutual support, and long continuity of relationships.
  • Are there potential iatrogenic effects of SG as suggested by the slowed improvement of depression and anxiety when compared to controls in the first SG study? Could mild iatrogenic effects occur in an early stage of an SG intervention that could be followed by substantial improvements (e.g., increased anxiety and depression while going through Steps 4 and 5 of Alcoholics Anonymous with significant improvements in emotional health following completion of these steps)?
I love the musing about the effect of this kind of service being delivered by alumni that have been out of treatment for a year. That opens up all sorts of interesting ideas, some having nothing to do with spiritual guidance. What about stage 2 recovery for those entering aftercare?

Monday, October 27, 2008

McCain and Obama on drug policy

The Fort Wayne News-Sentinel reports on Obama's and McCain's positions on drug policy.

Addiction Inbox also has posts on both candidates.

Bottom line: McCain wants to continue the drug war and Obama wants to promote drug courts and alternatives to incarceration.

Saturday, October 25, 2008

Things that make you go, "hmmm"

From Alcohol and Alcoholism:
Aims: Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is of great clinical importance not only because of its high prevalence but also due to the frequent comorbid illnesses that are connected with this disorder. Several studies were able to demonstrate that ADHD constitutes a significant risk factor for the exacerbation of habit-forming illnesses, i.e. addictions. Methods: We conducted a study on 152 adult patients with alcohol dependence (n = 91) or multiple substance addiction (n = 61) to determine whether or not these patients were affected by ADHD. For retrospective assessment of childhood ADHD, the WURS-k was used as well as the DSM-IV symptom checklist for ADHD. The CAARS was used to assess the persisting symptoms of ADHD in adults. Results: 20.9% (WURS-k) or 23.1% (DSM-IV diagnostic criteria) of the alcohol-dependent patients showed evidence of retrospective ADHD affliction in childhood. With the help of CAARS, ADHD was proved to be persistent in 33.3% of the adult patients. In the group of substance-addicted patients 50.8% (WURS-k) and 54.1% (DSM-IV) presented with diagnostic criteria for ADHD in childhood and 65.5% (CAARS) showed evidence of ADHD persisting in adulthood. Conclusions: These results reveal that habit-forming illnesses can be associated with a high comorbidity with ADHD, expressed in the form of alcohol abuse and also in consumption of illegal drugs. The results underline the great importance of early and adequate diagnostics and therapy of ADHD for the prevention of habit-forming illnesses.
What I find remarkable is not the co-occurrence of ADHD and AOD problems. Rather, that this finding is accepted, and a finding of high intelligence among people with alcohol problems is met with such skepticism. What does this say about the researchers? What questions are they not asking, or at least taking seriously? Is this a case of the ladder of inference at work?


Narcotic Farm

From Scientific American:

From 1935 to 1975, just about everyone busted for drugs in the U.S. was sent to the United States Narcotic Farm outside Lexington, Ky. Equal parts federal prison, treatment center, research laboratory and farm, this controversial institution was designed not only to rehabilitate addicts, but to discover a cure for drug addiction.

...the institution became a premier center for research into drug addiction and treatment, advancing everything from the use of methadone to treat heroin withdrawal to drugs that blocked the action of opiates. Along the way, Narco was frequented by legendary jazz musicians such as Chet Baker and Sonny Rollins, as well as actor Peter Lorre and beat generation writer William S. Burroughs, who recounted his experience in his first novel, Junkie.

The documentary also chronicles how the Farm was shut down when Congress discovered that researchers there were using patients as human guinea pigs in CIA-funded experiments into LSD. Drug research on federal prisoners is now illegal.

Still, the filmmakers note accomplishments at the institution remain milestones in addiction science and treatment. Its most important contribution might be how it transformed the way society views addicts—"as people suffering from a chronic, relapsing disorder that affects public health," says book co-author Nancy Campbell, an associate professor at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in Troy, N.Y., who studies the history of drug addiction research.

About the lower image:
The original caption for this photo, which appeared in a 1951 New York World-Telegram & Sun series on the Narcotic Farm, read: "This desperate narcotics addict, caught like his fellows in the revolving door of law enforcement, will probably go back to his habit when he is free."
Complete slide show here.

Info on the film here.

Info on the book.

UPDATE: The original article has since issued the following correction:
Correction (posted October 25, 2008): When originally posted, this story suggested that a Congressional investigation into the Narcotic Farm had led to its closure. In fact the main reason Narco was closed was that its centralized form of institutional care was supplanted by a national network of local treatment centers. Its closure coincided with the Congressional investigation into LSD research. Scientific American regrets the error.

Friday, October 24, 2008

Local policy news

The Ann Arbor News suggests that they would like to endorse a medical marijuana proposal, but this one isn't it.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

"unexpected findings"

I don't attribute a lot of significance to this, but I find it amusing that they state 3 times in this very brief press release that these findings are contrary to their expectations. It just CAN'T be true. Further examination is need.
NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Contrary to expectations, higher intelligence scores at age 10 may be associated with higher levels of alcohol intake and alcohol-related drinking problems during adulthood, study findings suggest.

Moreover, these associations appear "markedly stronger among women than among men," Dr. G. David Batty, from the University of Glasgow in Scotland, and colleagues report in the American Journal of Public Health.

However, "given that these findings ran counter to our expectations," the investigators call for further examination of this relationship.

Batty's team assessed associations between mental ability scores obtained when 8170 boys and girls were 10 years old and their alcohol intake and alcohol problems when they were about 30 years old.

Of the 3895 men and 4148 women who reported drinking alcohol as adults, those with higher average scores on childhood mental ability tests were also more likely to have indications of alcohol problems in adulthood.

The association between higher mental ability in childhood and adulthood problem drinking became stronger among women than among men after allowing for socioeconomic factors such as social class during both childhood and adulthood.

Specifically, for every 15-point increase in childhood mental ability score, the likelihood of drinking problems increased 1.38 times for women, and 1.17 times fro men

These unexpected findings, and the lack of other research in this area, indicate the need for "further examination of the relation between childhood IQ and adult drinking patterns," the investigators conclude.

SOURCE: American Journal of Public Health, October 2008
[Thanks Jess]

Monday, October 20, 2008

Local sentencing sense

The Ann Arbor News reports on the Washtenaw County Sobriety Court and our friend Judge Creal:
The defendant, who had been arrested for drunken driving, stood before 15th District Judge Julie Creal.

But unlike a typical sentencing, Creal asked questions of a more personal nature - wondering whether the death of a relative would impact the man's sobriety.

"I'm dealing with it," he said. "It's a tough time for me."

Creal asked how long he'd been sober.

"Sixteen months sober on Tuesday," he replied.

The nearly two dozen people stuffed in Creal's small courtroom for Washtenaw County's Sobriety Court broke into applause.

"Fabulous," Creal said as she clapped.

A judge who applauds? A group of defendants cheering each other's successes?

That's Sobriety Court, created by Creal four years ago to help repeat drunken drivers get treatment. Representatives from the prosecutor's office, city attorney's office, law enforcement and probation department also are present.

People who enter a voluntary, 18-month program and successfully complete it can avoid jail time and save about $1,000 in fines and fees. The program includes random testing at home, attendance at 12-step meetings, making small payments and staying sober.

Since it started, 157 people have entered the program. Of those who are no longer in the system, 60 have completed it successfully - a rate of about 76 percent.

The focus of the program is really about owning up to a problem.


I posted last week about how drug courts and health professional recovery programs are leading the way for the rest of us.

Methadone maintenance as palliative care

David Clark sticks his neck out on MMT:
As I have said many times before, I have nothing against methadone substitution therapy per se, but I feel strongly about it being used with clients being offered no, or only minimal other, support. I have written:

'Due to the approach adopted by much of the UK treatment system, this generally leads people from one addiction to another without providing a realistic opportunity to attain recovery.

Whilst methadone (and Subutex) have an important role to play in helping people take the chaos out of a heroin-using lifestyle, they should not be prescribed in isolation or with minimal other support.

The majority of heroin users actually want to get off drugs completely, not be “left” long-term on methadone or other substitute drugs. They must be provided with the choice of, and help in, finding a path to recovery, rather than just being helped to live with addiction. Much of the treatment system shows a shocking paucity of ambition for its clients. If cancer patients were only offered what amounts to a form of palliative care, it would be seen as a scandal.'
This issue of palliative care gets to the very crux of the issue doesn't it?

From Wikipedia:
The term "palliative care" may be used generally to refer to any care that alleviates symptoms, whether or not there is hope of a cure by other means;
It really comes down to whether once believes addiction is a treatable illness doesn't it?

I'd add that it might be possible for a methadone program to have a recovery orientation, rather than a palliative orientation, but it's not what I see.

Once again, I'd welcome a day when addicts are offered recovery oriented treatment of an adequate duration and intensity and have the opportunity to choose for themselves.

Sunday, October 19, 2008

Transformed...beyond hope

What is there to say?
The NAOMI study was funded by an $8.1-million research grant from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research.

The heroin and hydromorphone participants received three doses a day from health-care professionals in downtown clinics. Most participants - 192 - were from Vancouver. Fifty-nine were from Montreal.

After one year, 90 per cent of the addicts being provided heroin were still in the program and 54 per cent in the methadone program remained - much higher than the retention rates for conventional treatment, Dr. Schechter said.

Researchers said they found a decrease in criminal activity and use of street drugs, and an improvement in health among participants.

Participants must have been addicted to heroin for at least five years and attempted treatment twice in the past.

"This is a group that society has written off as beyond hope," Dr. Schechter said.
Once again, Emerson comes to mind:
This conformity makes them not false in a few particulars, authors of a few lies, but false in all particulars. Their every truth is not quite true. Their two is not the real two, their four not the real four ; so that every word they say chagrins us and we know not where to begin to set them right.
Two failed treatments and the best we can hope for is reduced crime, some improvements in health and persistence in showing up to receive free heroin? All for only $32,270 per participant?